I spent a lot of this book really frustrated with Piper and her obsession with the family blessing and trying to “fix” her family. But, after finishing, I think I understand her motives a little better (and I’m glad of the growth she showed).

All of her life, Piper’s aunts have convinced her that their family has been blessed by fate to have one perfect match, and once they find that match all will be well. But Piper’s parents have gotten divorced, her mom is now an outcast for going against the blessing, and Piper feels like she has to fix everything to be accepted by her family.

It doesn’t help that Piper never really feels like she fits in anywhere, except with her two best friends, due to her disability. She puts so much pressure on herself to find “the one” and to take over the family’s jewelry shop to continue the tradition. Even though she would much rather do something else.

Leo and Piper have been best friends forever. And he has probably been in love with her for almost as long, though she has been obsessed with her family’s gift and refuses to even consider Leo because he isn’t the one fate chose for her. This has caused issues in their friendship and causes a lot of tension when she finally does meet Forest, the one fate has chosen for her.

Her relationship with Forest is strained and forced at times. They seem to have nothing in common and all of their interactions are on the surface, with nothing deeper. Yeah, they’re high school seniors, but there still should be some depth in their relationship.

Seeing the way Piper interacts with everyone, trying to fit herself into their molds, was heartbreaking. But it was also frustrating because she just refused to see why the mold didn’t really fit. Even after she finally starts realizing things, she still chooses her extended family over her own happiness.

Watching Piper grow and finally admit that she would make different choices without the blessing was good. And I liked the way the story finished, with hope and joy.

Disclaimer: I received an eARC for review consideration though NetGalley, on behalf of the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.